Super Squads Analysis


The Brumbies may argue that 2018 was an improvement over 2017, after all they won 7 of their 16 starts, whereas 2017 had only given them 6 wins in a vastly different conference structure. Yes, in 2017 they also qualified for a quarterfinal spot, but that was not based on their overall performance, it was simply thanks to SANZAAR and Super Rugby’s weird geographical conference system and automatic qualification for the conference winners. Finishing 9th on the overall log, yet somehow automatically qualifying for a quarterfinal berth, and at home too! 

The reality was that 2018 was a disastrous season for the Brumbies. They might have won 6 games, but they finished the season with a negative points difference of -29. They finished one spot lower down the order than the year before, 10th out of 15 teams.

A dyed-in-the-wool Brumby supporter will say – “Yes, but look, we scored 56 tries in 2018, that is 15 more than we scored in 2017.” Yep, that is true, but in 2018 the Brumbies leaked 52 tries, twenty more than they conceded the previous year! 2018 is not a year the Brumbies will want to think about or talk about. Ever.

The 2019 coaching staff:

Head Coach: Dan McKellar

Assistant Coach: Laurie Fisher

Backs Coach: Peter Hewat

Director of Athletic Performance and Innovation: Ben Serpell

Strength and Conditioning Coach: John Mitchell

Changes in 2019

Players leaving

Thirteen of the 2018 squad have left the Brumby ranks. They are:

Robbie Abel (Auckland)
Ben Alexander (retired)
Richie Arnold (Yamaha Jubilo)
James Dargaville (North Harbour)
Mees Erasmus (Rebels)
Lolo Fakaosilea (Kintetsu Liners)
Kyle Godwin (Connacht)
Nic Mayhew (North Harbour)
Isi Naisarani (Rebels)
Michael Oakman-Hunt (Canberra Vikings)
Faalelei Sione (Manawatu)
Andrew Smith (Retired)
James Verity-Amm (released)

Losing Ben Alexander, Nic Mayhew and Robbie Abel removes plenty of the Brumbies front row experience, and they have lost Richie Arnold’s lineout presence as he has headed off to Japan. The departure of Kyle Godwin and James Dargaville will also hurt. 

The biggest loss is the departure of Isi Naisarani to the Rebels. The big, ball-carrying backrower combined well with David Pocock and provided the Brumbies with plenty of close-in go-forward oomph. He also scored no less than five of their tries in 2018. He will be missed.

Players arriving

Replacing the departees, the Brumbies were fortunate to secure the services of James Slipper to add some depth to the front row resources of current Wallabies Allan Alaalatoa and Scott Sio. Slipper brings plenty of experience and some good leadership skills too.

The signing of Toni Pulu, Murray Douglas and Pete Samu, all with Super Rugby experience playing out of New Zealand, adds some important skill and experience to the Brumby cupboard.

Perhaps the surprise package is the signing of the wayward Karmichael Hunt from the Reds. Hunt has a record for disciplinary problems and wayward adventures that involve illicit substances, and the Brumby management will need to keep a very close eye on him.

Other signings include, Bayley Kuenzle, Len Ikitau, Noah Lolesio, and Irae Simone. 

Incoming players

Murray Douglas (Hurricanes)
Vunipola Fifita (Canberra Vikings)
Len Ikitau (Canberra Vikings)
Bayley Kuenzle (Southern Districts)
Noah Lolesio (Canberra Vikings)
Toni Pulu (Chiefs)
Tom Ross (Canberra Vikings)
Pete Samu (Crusaders)
Irae Simone (Waratahs)
James Slipper (Reds)


David Pocock remains key to the Brumbies fortunes in 2019. He is likely to be rested frequently and his game time will be carefully managed as he has taken a lot of punishment in the last couple of years, and his neck seems to be an issue. They will need to use his playing time very carefully.

The arrival of Karmichael Hunt might help solve a problem in the flyhalf and midfield positions, but he has been out of serious rugby for a year, and blows hot and cold, even when in top form. If he can keep his wayward instincts under control, he might well pay dividends.

Playing Squad, by Position

1 Scott Sio, James Slipper
2 Folau Fainga’a, Connal McInerney
3 Allan Alaalatoa, Les Makin
4 Rory Arnold, Sam Carter
5 Blake Enever, Murray Douglas
6 Pete Samu, Tom Cusack
7 David Pocock, Lachlan McCaffrey
8 Rob Valetini, Ben Hyne
9 Joe Powell, Matt Lucas
10 Karmichael Hunt, Wharenui Hawera, Bayley Kuenzle
11 Toni Pulu, Henry Speight
12 Christian Lealiifano, Tom Wright
13 Tevita Kuridrani, Len Ikitau/Irae Simone
14 Chance Peni, Lausii Taliauli
15 Tom Banks, Andy Muirhead


The Brumbies have some very good front line players, the likes of Pocock, Tom Banks, Kuridrani, Speight, Samu, Pulu, Sio, and Alaalatoa. (Some might add Hunt to that list, but the jury remains out on that one.)

The problem is with depth in the squad. If the front liners are injured, or rested as they surely will be in a World Cup year, there is very little else to talk about.

Of course, the Brumbies could ride on their good fortune of having most of the games against fellow Aussie teams, but the reality is that they will need to produce something of a rugby miracle to do better than last year.

Predicted finish: 2nd or 3rd in the Aussie conference. Probably 3rd.